11 Comments
User's avatar
Dominika's avatar

I've been meaning to read Shūsaku but have been nervous to pick up Silence because of how intense it sounds. I might have to read this one first. Even though it also sounds intense, I've had a long devotion to St. Maximilian Kolbe. I visited his cell at Auschwitz with my family when I was in the fourth grade, and his story has been imprinted on my heart ever since.

Expand full comment
Melody Schwarting's avatar

Silence is so intense (but worth it at least once if you ever feel up to it). This book has different questions, and I found it more...edifying?...to read. At least, I've read it twice, where I doubt I'll re-read Silence for decades, and likely never watch the film adaptation, given the effect the novel had on me! With your devotion to St Maximilian Kolbe I'm sure you will find much to ponder here. In some ways he is the catalyst of the whole novel...but I'll just have to wait to hear your thoughts! :)

Expand full comment
Dominika's avatar

Yep, even if I read Silence, I have ZERO plans to watch the film. I’m such a sensitive viewer.

Expand full comment
Elizabeth Brink's avatar

Thank you Melody! This sounds like an incredible read. I haven't heard of it before, and I know very little about Japanese history or culture or its literature. Ack!

Expand full comment
Melody Schwarting's avatar

I'm just beginning to learn myself. This translation was only published in 2018. Silence is so famous (deservedly) but I've found riches in Endō's other work too. We are living in a great age for translated Japanese literature!

Expand full comment
Elizabeth Brink's avatar

That is such good news!

Expand full comment
Dawn Duryea's avatar

This sounds so deep and thoughtful. I really enjoyed Silence and so I will have to read this now too! Thanks for highlighting this work and giving such a powerful endorsement. I am glad that you are sharing all these wonderful works that you read. Thank you!

Expand full comment
Melody Schwarting's avatar

Thank you, Dawn! In the past decade or more and more of Endō's work has been published in English, and I'm so grateful! He writes so powerfully, and while this novel's subject is not light, it was less painful than Silence in some places, and the characters stuck with me.

Expand full comment
Dawn Duryea's avatar

I can imagine. The horrors that the Japanese endured during that time boggle the mind. The fact that some of them can write about it now is a blessing for us. But pain is part of life and I think if the author can somehow convey how he came to integrate that fact into his understanding it is worth reading.

Expand full comment
Craig's avatar

Wow! That is quite a story ... hard to hear, yet harder to live. Thank you for sharing!

Expand full comment
Melody Schwarting's avatar

Thank you, Craig! It is a joy to share Endō's work. He had a profound faith that always challenges me.

Expand full comment